Research Institute · Programme

Direct sums, wedges and the p14 frontier

Proving additivity of multiplicative complexity across disjoint monomial blocks and uncoupled matrix multiplications over GF(2).

Published 2026-08-29 · updated 2026-09-04

40results
15machine-checked
10negative results
11open cells

The programme

Where things stand

What this programme is about

When digital circuits compute two independent mathematical operations at once, we expect the total number of multiplications to equal the sum of their individual costs. This programme tests whether shared intermediate products can beat that additive baseline in Boolean logic over GF(2). It concentrates on two concrete problems: whether batching independent operations like 2×2 matrix multiplication or polynomial multiplication can share nonlinear gates, and whether a 26-input Cartesian period-two carry circuit can run in 14 AND gates. In cryptographic proof systems and hardware design, multiplications over GF(2) dominate runtime and circuit area. Settling these bounds tells engineers exactly when parallel tasks can compress into smaller circuits and when searching for further gate reductions is mathematically futile.

What has been settled

MF-163 proves that unrestricted multiplicative complexity is strictly additive when one function meets its linear rank floor or both functions have complexity two; the rank floor carries folklore prior art, while the two-function case is new. Exhaustive DRAT proofs settle MC(x1x2x3 ⊕ y1y2y3y4) = 5 in ML-077. Binary polynomial multiplication MC(polymul_3 over F2) = 6 is proved in MF-148, matching Karatsuba benchmarks. For 2×2 matrix multiplication over GF(2), MF-149 and MF-180 narrow complexity to [6,7], establishing the first unrestricted lower bound of 6, while MF-086 credits Alder and Strassen for the 7s bound in bilinear models. In ML-061, tensor rank fails to transfer lower bounds to unrestricted circuits, noting prior art by Mirwald–Schnorr, Find–Boyar, and Ballet et al. for GF(4) cost 3.

MF-084 proves the separated-product theorem holds over any field under square closure, correcting the field-general reading in MF-032. The mixed-image tax in MF-085 proves that computing an r-dimensional separated quotient in r gates forces every independent target gate to be copy-local. MF-097 confirms that degree r+1 outputs in XOR–AND circuits have decomposable top forms, recording that an earlier scope flag on MF-001 was withdrawn. A four-product counterexample in MF-074 disproves the laminar multiplication-tree normal form.

On the p14 frontier, MF-037 and MF-047 prove standalone wedges intersect the ten-dimensional target in dimension 4, forcing at least six non-input-only gates. MF-034 eliminates all 11-wedge variants, all 8-wedge seeds, and 130 rank-tight 7-wedge seeds. Across affine codes, ML-043 closes all 68 p7-eligible directed edges under zero-catalyst rank-tight rules, aggregating MF-070, MF-071, and MF-072. Finally, MF-121 refutes the general carry-bond tensor floor at J_2, and MF-178 proves tensor slice rank cannot beat the linear dimension floor.

What is still open

The existence of a 14-product circuit for the Cartesian period-two carry target remains unsolved. In MF-124, which supersedes the 817-cell count in MF-105, automated search eliminated 596 candidate cells, leaving 221 surviving decomposition cells alongside the unresolved 12 named frontiers from ML-026. Conjectured structures for this target include a rank-two bilinear bridge gate MF-035, persistent savings under period doubling MF-038, and a lower bound of 15 products MF-039. For matrix multiplication, deciding whether 2×2 matrices over GF(2) require 6 or 7 AND gates ML-088 leaves functional direct-sum additivity open in unrestricted Boolean logic ML-051; the decision instance stands at 155,669 CNF clauses. Other open targets include whether extension-field batching can beat direct-sum additivity MF-014, the unproved summation steps of the FCNS reduction chain MF-112, and the 3-form quadratic transfer gap at 6 variables ML-075.

How to read the evidence

Exhaustive checks and computational receipts dominate this programme's settled results, supported by certified DRAT proofs and written mathematical arguments. Exhaustive checks provide absolute certainty across finite search spaces by ruling out every candidate assignment for specific gate counts and affine-code edges. Receipts log verified solver runs and Gröbner basis reductions. Certified proofs guarantee mechanical auditability. Readers can trust the finite impossibility results completely. Open cells remain unresolved computational bottlenecks awaiting larger searches or new reductions.

Showcase

The strongest results here

MF-084CERTIFIED PROOF

The separated-product theorem over any field under square closure

If u ∈ U ⟹ u² ∈ U and v ∈ V ⟹ v² ∈ V, the separated-product theorem holds over any field k

Over any field, the separated-product theorem holds when each component signal space is closed under squaring, and without that condition mixed factors can produce new separated terms.

Prior art: This entry builds on predecessor MF-032; no position on external prior art is stated.

structure theoremDirect sums, wedges and the p14 frontierfull paper

Published 2026-08-29

MF-086PAPER PROOF

Multiplicative complexity of independent copies of 2×2 matrix multiplication over GF(2)

rank_CP/bilinear(M₂^⊕s) = 7s, MC_formal-quadratic(M₂^⊕s) = 7s over GF(2)

For s independent copies of 2x2 matrix multiplication over GF(2), CP or bilinear rank and formal-quadratic multiplicative complexity are both exactly 7s, but the unrestricted Boolean XAG model is not covered.

Prior art: The 7s value is credited to Alder-Strassen and Strassen under bilinear and formal-quadratic models, but this result has not been established for unrestricted Boolean settings.

exact determinationDirect sums, wedges and the p14 frontierfull paper

Published 2026-08-29

MF-148EXHAUSTIVE CHECK

Exact unrestricted multiplicative complexity of 3-term binary polynomial multiplication

MC(polymul_3 over F2) = 6 in the unrestricted model

The exact multiplicative complexity of multiplying two 3-term polynomials over GF(2) is proved to be 6 in the unrestricted model via three independent derivations.

Prior art: This is a known value obtained using classical Karatsuba multiplication for the NIST binary-polynomial category. It remains only a partial result regarding exactness in an unrestricted model.

exact determinationDirect sums, wedges and the p14 frontierfull paper

Published 2026-09-04

MF-163RECEIPTED

Direct-sum theorems and lower bounds for unrestricted multiplicative complexity

MC(F ⊕ G) ≥ dim V(F) + MC(G) with MC(F ⊕ G) = MC(F) + MC(G) if min(e(F), e(G)) = 0 or if dim V(F) = dim V(G) = 1 and MC(F) = MC(G) = 2

The number of multiplications needed to compute two independent functions together is proved to equal the sum of their individual complexities whenever at least one function meets its linear rank floor or both have complexity two.

Prior art: Theorem A and the rank floor are partly known or likely folklore (BPP 2000; Mirwald–Schnorr for the quadratic model). Theorem D appears new: no direct-sum theorem was found for unrestricted Boolean complexity, with the nearest precedents being Strassen additivity, Shitov's refutation, Feig 1984, and KRW for formula depth.

structure theoremDirect sums, wedges and the p14 frontierfull paper

Published 2026-09-04

MF-164OPEN QUESTION

Exact multiplicative complexity of direct sums of monomial Boolean functions

MC(x1x2x3 ⊕ y1y2y3y4) = 5, MC(x1x2x3 ⊕ y1y2y3) = 4, and additivity holds across all tested direct-sum cells

Multiplicative complexity is shown to be strictly additive across several benchmark direct sums, including proving that x1x2x3 ⊕ y1y2y3y4 requires exactly 5 AND gates.

Prior art: Using standard methods from Calik–Turan–Peralta (ePrint 2015/848, 2018/002; arXiv 2005.01778), these specific direct-sum cells fall outside the n <= 6 census and appear to be new. The additivity conjecture remains open after three searches.

conjecture open problemDirect sums, wedges and the p14 frontierfull paper

Published 2026-09-04

MF-166RECEIPTED NEGATIVE RESULT

Exact multiplicative complexity of a Fano 3-space at n = 8 and floor census at n = 4

For explicit Fano W <= Λ^2(F2^8) with dim W = 3, m_2(W) = 6 and qMC(W) = MC(W) = 7 = dim W + 4.

A specific 3-dimensional space of quadratic forms in 8 variables has multiplicative complexity exactly 7, achieving an excess of 4 over its dimension without higher-order transfers, alongside an exhaustive gap census at 4 variables.

Prior art: This result is partial, and its novelty remains unverified because simplex-code packing is conceptually a standard technique in coding theory.

exact determinationDirect sums, wedges and the p14 frontierfull paper

Published 2026-09-04

MF-180RECEIPTED

Multiplicative complexity bounds for 2x2 matrix multiplication over GF(2)

6 ≤ MC(M_2(F_2)) ≤ 7 in sequential XAG over F_2, with qMC(W) ≥ 6 for an invariant 2-plane W ⊂ Λ^2(F_2^8)

The multiplicative complexity of 2x2 matrix multiplication over GF(2) in the sequential XAG model is constrained to between 6 and 7 by combining Strassen's upper bound with a subfield invariant lower bound.

Prior art: This is a partial and apparently new result, establishing the first non-bilinear lower bound >= 6 for unrestricted XAG over F_2.

lower boundDirect sums, wedges and the p14 frontierfull paper

Published 2026-09-04

Every entry

The rest of the programme

Every confirmed result in this programme. Each links to its full paper.

Snapshot 2026-09-06. Generated from the division's registers and curation records; never hand-edited.